One killed and dozens injured on the way to Singapore. Boeing again in turbulance.

Quarky

Well-known member
Bit different story...

"The rapid changes in G over the 4.6 sec duration resulted in an altitude drop of 178 ft, from 37,362 ft to 37,184 ft. This sequence of events likely caused the injuries to the crew and passengers."
6000 feet in five seconds always sounded a bit dodgy... that would have obliterated the plane!

178 feet is bad enough...
 

Nomad

Well-known member
From ChatGPT. Implying it wasn't the descent in total but more likely the manner of the descent.

Commercial Jet Airliners: During a normal descent, a commercial jet might descend at about 1,000 to 3,000 feet per minute. This rate can be faster in certain phases or under specific air traffic control instructions, potentially reaching up to 4,000 feet per minute for a brief period.

  • For a descent rate of 1,000 feet per minute:
    • As previously noted, 1,000 feet per minute converts to approximately 16.67 feet per second.
    • 4.6seconds=76.681feet
  • For a descent rate of 3,000 feet per minute:
    • 3,000 feet per minute converts to approximately 50 feet per second.
    • 4.6seconds=230feet
 

Bacon

Administrator
The suss bit is the "uncommanded increase in altitude"..."most likely due to the aircraft being acted upon by an updraft"

Right.

Wind by itself lifted a heavy aircraft against the force of the jets under autopilot control? If that's how wind worked, every parked aircraft would be in danger of becoming suddenly airborne in a gust of wind. Jetstreams can alleviate pressure off engines, but lifting the aircraft sounds far fetched. When was the last time anyone here suddenly experienced the opposite of turbulance drop? Even the report itself is unsure. Most likely? What? The data doesn't say? Riiiiight.
 

kaptainrob

Administrator
The suss bit is the "uncommanded increase in altitude"..."most likely due to the aircraft being acted upon by an updraft"

Right.

Wind by itself lifted a heavy aircraft against the force of the jets under autopilot control? If that's how wind worked, every parked aircraft would be in danger of becoming suddenly airborne in a gust of wind. Jetstreams can alleviate pressure off engines, but lifting the aircraft sounds far fetched. When was the last time anyone here suddenly experienced the opposite of turbulance drop? Even the report itself is unsure. Most likely? What? The data doesn't say? Riiiiight.
Updrafts are quite common, especially over mountain ranges or hot land areas such as deserts.

A small updraft can easily provide lift and precede turbulent downdrafts. Updrafts alone often cause a bumpy ride and nothing too severe.
 

Bacon

Administrator
Updrafts are quite common, especially over mountain ranges or hot land areas such as deserts.

A small updraft can easily provide lift and precede turbulent downdrafts. Updrafts alone often cause a bumpy ride and nothing too severe.
I stand corrected.

Maybe I'm putting circumstantial stuff together at a time Boeing is going through safety dramas due to greed and cost cutting, which is very much real. Plus there was that second incident not long after, in the midst of a slew of incident reports we've had. But then my critical mind also tells me that more regular incident reports might be bubbling up to the media surface due to momentum, which otherwise wouldn't normally get much attention.

Incidentally I'm flying on the same plane next month. I checked my booking a few days ago and went... ahhhh great... 😅 I know, it's irrational,
 

Cuzzy

Well-known member
On the news tonight. IATA talking about seat belts being mandatory at all times now. Due of course to recent events.

I have, in the past, been pretty blase' about wearing a belt while flying but insist on it when driving. That doesn't really make sense. Having spent so much time flying without incident gave me an irrational sense of safety.

We've got a trip back to visit the family over December and January and seat belts will be on all the time. I don't really fancy head butting the overhead lockers.
 

Nomad

Well-known member
Had flights to Sydney and Auckland this week. A small amount of turbulence on 2 flights and flight attendants were asked to stop serving and be seated.
 

Cuzzy

Well-known member
So what happens to that SIA plane after that event? Does it get a good going over to make sure it's structural integrity is good enough to fly again?
 

kaptainrob

Administrator
Sitting in Nok Air plane one time looking out the window thats exactly what i saw on the engine cowling :eek:

I know it's good stuff as i've used kms of it on bikes over the years but a plane.....seriously?? 55
I've seen Emirates 777s with more speed tape around the wing box to fuselage than paint. It's very good as a temporary repair to maintain aerodynamics ahead of major servicing and repaint.

Not regular duct tape.
 

kaptainrob

Administrator
I call it cloth tape (other bike racers called it 200mph tape) and yes it's very strong.
I always took the cloth tape as part of my spares inventory on boat deliveries. Used it once when we had a near sinking 50nm off Shoalhaven to bind up up and 8 inch exhaust hose which split. Speed tape is thinner aluminium foil and which very sticky it lacks the sheer strength of cloth tape. We tend to label them all generically as 'duct' tape.
 

Quarky

Well-known member
For many years I thought it was duck tape.

 

kaptainrob

Administrator
^ Used on everything except actual ducts.
General purpose duct and speed tape are similar although I believe the latter to be of a higher grade Aluminium and adhesive to withstand extremes of temperature. The former is in fact used for sealing aircon ductwork and I've used it on homemade structures to seal joints and cover rivets. It's not easy to use as so thin and tears easily during handling.
 
Top